94 Points - Tim Atkin SA Special Report 2024
94 Points - Julie Sheppard, Decanter, March 2024
93 Points - James Suckling
94 Tim Atkin MW, SA Special Report 2024
Emul Ross and proprietor Anthony Hamilton Russell are not afraid to make Pinot Noirs with structure and staying power, even in a wetter vintage like 2023. This has plenty of colour, lots of spicy Francois Freres oak, some underlying ferrous trip, savoury tannins and flavours of plum and black cherry. Substantial, but give it time.
Jonathan Ray, The Spectator, April 2024
...this is sensual and elegant, showing what beauty there is in young Pinot. With its signature purity, spice and touch of savouriness, it will age magnificently, too. And, again, with Burgundy prices going bonkers, this is an utter must for lovers of top-notch sophisticated Pinot.
94 Julie Sheppard, Decanter, March 2024
There's lovely purity of red berry and cherry fruit on the nose, woven through with earthier savoury and spice hints. That savoury nuance persists on the elegant palate, alongside delicate raspberry and red cherry notes, with fine tannins and a whisper of smoke that emphasises the persistent mineral character. Still young, this will age beautifully.
91 Neal Martin, Vinous, September 2024
Fresh and vibrant, the palate is medium-bodied with crunchy red fruit, a crisp line of acidity and a touch of sour cherry on the finish. Very fine.
93 James Suckling
A tight, spicy and savory pinot noir that has aromas of herbal tea, citrus rind, rust, cranberries and wild mushrooms. It’s medium-bodied, firm and well framed. Long and focused.
News 24, Wine Editor's Five Most Exciting Vino Finds, Daléne Fourie, February 2026
So I have to confess, this wine I found via a cellar auction, sold out in favour of the current 2024 vintage. Classic, old-world-inspired Pinot Noir. I always remember Anthony Hamilton Russell telling me that he liked wine that had developed and had faint twangs of ancient man on it – thus, even this can be considered too young to consume at three years old.
But it was fabulous. An underlying iron grip, savoury tannins, big and substantial – meant to age. Classic is not a swear word.